To buy share coowner property transactions look ordinary until the record is searched. The seller produces a deed, describes himself as the absolute owner, and signs an agreement for the full plot. The khatian then shows four names, and the four names include a sister who lives in another state and a brother who has not spoken to the seller in a decade. The buyer has not bought a plot; he has bought a quarter of one, along with the right to sue for partition.
How the trap is set
The trap is set in the recitals. A deed executed by one co-owner frequently recites that the seller is "the absolute owner and in exclusive possession" of the property, and that there is no other person with any right, title or interest. Those recitals are false when the seller holds only a share, and they are the reason buyers do not ask the next question.
The second part of the trap is possession. The seller is living on the plot or has let it out, and the buyer sees a person in possession and assumes a sole owner. In fact every co-owner is entitled to possession of the whole, which is why the seller looks like an owner.
The third part is the mutation record. If the seller has managed to mutate the property in his own name, the record looks clean, and the buyer's advocate has to go back to the parent deed to see that the mutation was obtained without notice to the other co-owners.
What the law gives the buyer
Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 limits the transfer to the seller's share and gives the buyer the transferor's right to joint possession and to enforce a partition. The buyer is a co-owner with the other sharers, and he owns a fraction of every part of the property. He cannot point to a plot and say it is his.
If the seller had no title at all, the buyer gets nothing and must sue the seller for the return of the price and for damages on the covenant for title. If the seller had a share, the buyer gets that share, and the deed is not void; it is simply smaller than the buyer believed.
The three ways to structure the purchase
- Buy from all the co-owners. Every person on the record signs the deed, and the deed conveys the whole property. This is the clean route, and it requires the cooperation of the whole family.
- Partition first, then buy a plot. The co-owners execute a registered partition deed allotting specific plots to each, or obtain a partition decree, and the buyer then purchases the allotted plot from its sole owner. The partition costs stamp duty, but it converts a share into a plot.
- Buy the share at a discount and sue for partition. The buyer purchases the undivided share knowing what it is, pays a price reflecting the discount and the delay, and files a partition suit immediately. This works where the buyer has the patience and the legal budget for a suit.
A fourth route, common in practice, is a deed of confirmation from the other co-owners after the purchase, ratifying the sale. It is cheaper than a partition, but it depends on the same cooperation that the partition requires, and it does not give the buyer a defined portion.
Due diligence that would have caught it
- The khatian and the plot information from Banglarbhumi, read against the deed, and the old khatian from the district record room where the current record looks too clean.
- The parent deed, to see how the seller acquired the property and whether he acquired a share or the whole.
- The death certificates and the family tree of the person from whom the property came, to identify every heir who should be on the record.
- The mutation file, to check whether notice went to every recorded owner.
- The municipal assessment and the tax receipts, to see in whose name the property has been assessed.
- The sub-registrar's search, to see whether the other co-owners have already sold their shares to someone else.
None of this is expensive, and most of it can be done before the token amount is paid. The buyer who pays first and investigates later has lost the leverage that the investigation would have given him.
The recital that the seller is the absolute owner is a statement by the seller, not a finding by the registrar. Only the search and the record can test it.
When the family partitions without the buyer
After the sale, the family may partition the property among themselves and allot the buyer's share to the least valuable parcel, or ignore him altogether. A partition to which the buyer is not a party does not bind his share, but he has to go to court to establish that, and the court will examine whether the partition was genuine and whether the buyer was given notice.
A buyer who files his partition suit promptly is in a much better position. The suit brings all the co-owners before the court, prevents a collusive partition from acquiring the appearance of a fact, and allows the court to allot a portion by metes and bounds.
Common questions
Can I get my money back if the seller had only a share?
You can claim the difference between the price paid and the value of the share actually received, on the covenant for title and any indemnity in the deed. The claim is against the seller, not against the other co-owners, and it is a money suit within three years of the discovery of the defect.
Does the buyer of a share have to pay the full stamp duty?
The duty is computed on the value of the share transferred, which is a proportion of the market value of the whole property. The registering authority assesses it on that basis, and the buyer should ensure the deed states the share precisely so that the assessment is not made on the whole.
Can the co-owners buy me out?
Where the property is a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family, the other co-owners can apply to the court to purchase the buyer's share at a valuation under the proviso to Section 44, and the court can allow it. For other property, the co-owners can negotiate a purchase but cannot compel one; the remedy is partition and, where division is impractical, a sale.
Is a share in a flat different?
Yes, in practice. A flat is usually held through a society share and an apartment, and the society's records and bye-laws govern the transfer. The co-ownership problem arises where the flat itself is in joint names or where the seller inherited an undivided interest, and the society's consent and the share transfer become part of the due diligence.
Search the record before you believe the recital, and structure the purchase as a purchase of the whole or of a defined plot. A share bought at the right discount can still be a good deal, but only if the buyer knows that a partition suit is part of the price. Our title practice runs the record search and the family tree, and the partition practice converts a share into a defined portion. Where the family will cooperate, the registration team prepares the partition deed.