14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Personal guarantor liability after a corporate default

A director who signs a personal guarantee remains liable for the company's debt after the company goes into insolvency, and the approval of a resolution plan does not wipe the guarantee out. That is the settled position, and it is the reason personal guarantor liability ibc is now a distinct area of practice: banks pursue the guarantor while the corporate process runs, and in some cases they initiate insolvency against the guarantor as an individual. The guarantee is co-extensive with the principal debt, and the creditor is not obliged to exhaust its remedies against the company first.

The guarantee, and what it obliges

A guarantee is a contract by which one person promises to answer for the debt of another. Under the Contract Act, the surety's liability is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless the contract limits it, and the creditor may proceed against the surety immediately, without suing the principal debtor at all. The guarantee deed fixes the amount, the period and the conditions, and those terms decide most disputes.

A director who signs a guarantee in a personal capacity, with a personal asset schedule or without one, is bound personally. A director who signs only on behalf of the company is not, and the distinction turns on the signature block and the words of the deed, not on the title in the board resolution.

Pursuing the guarantor while the company is in insolvency

The moratorium that freezes proceedings against the corporate debtor does not extend to the guarantor. The creditor can therefore do three things at once: participate in the committee of creditors for the company, proceed against the guarantor under the guarantee, and, where the guarantor is an individual, initiate insolvency proceedings against him.

  • Recovery proceedings: a bank can proceed before the debt recovery tribunal on the basis of its recovery certificate, and the tribunal can order the guarantor's personal assets to be sold.
  • Insolvency against the guarantor: the Code's provisions for personal guarantors to corporate debtors allow an application to the tribunal that is hearing the company's process, and the guarantor's own resolution process follows.
  • Civil suit: a suit on the guarantee, filed within the limitation period, where the debt is not within the tribunal's jurisdiction.
  • Enforcement of security: where the guarantor has mortgaged his own property, the creditor can enforce that mortgage, subject to the terms of the deed.

What does not discharge the guarantor

The approval of a resolution plan for the company does not discharge the guarantor, and that has been the position since the personal guarantor provisions were upheld. The reasoning is that the guarantee is a separate contract, and the creditor's decision to accept a reduced amount from the company is a decision about the company's debt, not a waiver of the guarantee.

A guarantee therefore survives the resolution, the liquidation, and the settlement of the company's account. It also survives the extinction of the company by striking off in most situations, and the creditor can proceed on the strength of the guarantee deed and the record of the debt.

The defences that work

  1. The guarantee was limited: the deed caps the amount, or covers only a particular facility, and the bank's claim exceeds the cap or relates to a different facility.
  2. Material variation without consent: the bank varied the terms of the loan — increased the limit, extended the tenure, changed the rate — without the guarantor's consent, and the variation prejudiced him.
  3. Release or substitution: the bank released a co-guarantor or a security without reserving its rights, which can discharge the surety to that extent.
  4. Limitation: the claim against the guarantor is time-barred because the bank neither invoked the guarantee nor acknowledged it within the period.
  5. No default: the account was regularised, or the claim includes amounts that were never disbursed.
  6. Execution defects: the deed was not properly executed, the signature was obtained on a blank document, or the guarantee was given by a person who lacked capacity.

The defence that rarely works is that the guarantor did not benefit from the loan. A guarantee is not a gift and does not require consideration to flow to the surety; the bank's forbearance to the company is consideration enough, and the guarantor's relationship with the company is irrelevant to his liability.

Insolvency against a personal guarantor

Where the creditor chooses the insolvency route against the guarantor, the process is different from a corporate resolution. The application goes to the tribunal that has jurisdiction over the corporate debtor's process, and it is accompanied by the guarantee deed, the record of the debt and the evidence of default. The tribunal appoints a resolution professional, and a repayment plan is prepared and put to the creditors for approval. The plan binds the guarantor if it is approved, and if it is not, the guarantor may be declared bankrupt, with the consequences that follow for his assets.

The threshold and the limitation apply equally to this route, and a guarantee that is time-barred cannot be revived by filing an insolvency application.

Practical points for a director

The time to deal with a personal guarantee is before it is signed. Read the amount, the facilities covered, whether it is a continuing guarantee, whether it can be revoked, and what the bank's rights are on a variation. A continuing guarantee can be revoked by notice for future transactions, and the revocation must reach the bank in writing.

Once the company defaults, keep every communication with the bank. A bank that restructured the loan without informing the guarantor has changed the risk he undertook, and the correspondence is the evidence. Do not sign a revival or acknowledgement letter without advice: an acknowledgement extends limitation, and a revival letter can create a fresh liability where the original had become time-barred.

Where it is fought in Kolkata

Recovery proceedings against a guarantor go before the Debts Recovery Tribunal at Kolkata, where the bank's claim exceeds the tribunal's threshold, and before the City Civil Court where it does not. Insolvency against the guarantor goes before the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata bench, on the strength of its jurisdiction over the corporate debtor's process. The insolvency practice appears in both forums, the banking and finance practice advises on the guarantee deed and the restructuring, and a claim that has to be defended as a money suit is handled under recovery suits. The company law consequences of a director's insolvency are dealt with under corporate law.

Can the bank proceed against me without suing the company?

Yes. The surety's liability is co-extensive, and the creditor may proceed against the guarantor alone. The bank is not obliged to exhaust its remedies against the company first, though in practice it usually proceeds against both.

Does the resolution plan reduce my guarantee?

Not unless the plan or a separate agreement expressly discharges the guarantor. The approval of a plan extinguishes the company's balance debt, not the guarantee.

Can I be made bankrupt for a guarantee?

Yes, through the personal insolvency provisions. The process requires an application, a resolution professional and a repayment plan, and if no plan is approved the guarantor may be declared bankrupt.

How long does a guarantee last?

A continuing guarantee lasts until it is revoked by notice for future transactions, or until the debt is discharged. The claim on the guarantee is subject to limitation, which runs from the date the guarantee could be enforced.

A guarantee is a personal liability taken on a company's risk. Read it before signing, keep the correspondence after a default, and do not acknowledge the debt without advice — those three habits decide most of these cases.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422