Where a property has two or more co-owners, a sale of the whole requires every co-owner to join the deed. A sale by one co-owner transfers only his undivided share, and the buyer becomes a co-owner with the others, entitled to joint possession but not to any specific part of the property. There is no provision in Indian law by which a majority of co-owners can sell the whole over the objection of the minority.
That rule is simple, and it is the source of a great deal of litigation, because families market a property as a whole, find a buyer, and only then discover that one brother will not sign.
The statutory position
Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides that where one of two or more joint owners of immovable property transfers his interest, the transferee acquires the transferor's interest, and has the right to joint possession with the other owners, to the extent of that interest.
The transferee does not acquire a right to exclusive possession of any part, and he cannot compel the other co-owners to partition the property in his favour. He can sue for partition, and the Partition Act, 1893 gives the other co-owners a right, in defined circumstances, to buy him out instead.
Where all the co-owners join the deed, the buyer takes the whole, and the sale is complete. Where only some join, the buyer takes the shares of those who signed, and the deed should say so expressly, so that the buyer knows what he has bought and the price reflects it.
Who must sign
- Every co-owner recorded in the deed and in the record of rights, in the share he holds.
- The heirs of a co-owner who has died, after the mutation is completed in their names.
- The guardian of a minor co-owner, with the sanction of the court where the sale of the minor's share is involved.
- The executor or the legatees, where a share devolved under a will, with probate where it is required.
- The holder of a power of attorney, only under a registered power that is still in force, and the power should be annexed to the deed.
- The mortgagee's consent or a discharge, where the property is charged.
The society's no-objection is not a statutory consent to the transfer, but the society's records have to be updated, and most buyers and lenders will insist on it. For a flat, the share certificate and the society's transfer formalities are part of the transaction even though they are not part of the conveyance.
When a co-owner refuses
If the co-owners had agreed in writing to sell jointly, and one of them later refuses, the buyer can sue for specific performance against the refusing co-owner. The agreement must be signed by all, or by someone authorised by all, and the buyer must show readiness and willingness to perform.
Where there is no such agreement, the refusing co-owner cannot be compelled to sell. The buyer's options are to buy the shares of those who will sell, at a price that reflects the co-ownership, or to walk away. Buying into a co-ownership dispute is rarely a good decision for a buyer who wants the whole property.
A co-owner who refuses may also be acting in the family's interest, because the price is inadequate or the buyer is unsuitable. The court will not override a refusal that is exercised in good faith, and the remedy for the others is to buy him out or to sue for partition.
The deed when all join
The deed should recite the shares of each seller, the title by which they hold, the total consideration and its apportionment among them, the delivery of possession, and the indemnity. The apportionment matters for two reasons: each seller's capital gains are computed on his share, and a dispute about the division of the price is a dispute the deed should have prevented.
Where the shares are unequal, the deed should state the share of each seller expressly, and the record of rights should be checked to confirm it. A deed that assumes equal shares when the khatian records otherwise is a deed that the buyer's advocate will query, and the query will delay the registration.
The deed should also deal with the pending dues. Property tax, electricity, water and society maintenance are apportioned as between the sellers, and the buyer should obtain a no-dues statement. A co-owner who has not paid his share of the tax can leave the property with arrears that the corporation will recover from the land.
The buyer's protection
The buyer should trace the title of every co-owner, not merely the one who is negotiating. Each share has its own chain: an inheritance, a partition, a gift, a sale. A defect in one chain affects that share, and the buyer who has bought the whole discovers that he owns five-sixths and faces a suit for the rest.
The buyer should also check that no co-owner has already sold or mortgaged his share. A sale of an undivided share is registrable, and the registration search will disclose it. A mortgage of an undivided share is also registrable, and the bank's charge follows the share.
Where a co-owner has died, his heirs must be brought on the record before the sale, and each heir must join. A sale that ignores a daughter, or a widow, is a sale that can be challenged for the share they were entitled to, however long ago the death occurred.
Buying a share, and the partition that follows
A buyer who acquires one co-owner's share has two routes. He can hold the share and wait, taking the income in proportion, or he can sue for partition and have the property divided or sold.
If he sues for partition, the other co-owners can apply under section 4 of the Partition Act to buy him out at a valuation fixed by the court, provided the property is a dwelling house or the circumstances bring it within the section. That is a real risk, and a buyer of an undivided share should know it before he pays.
The alternative is a negotiated buy-out, where the co-owners purchase the share at a price agreed, and the deed records the release. That is often cheaper for everyone than a partition suit.
The Kolkata forums
The sale deed is registered at the sub-registrar's office for the area, and the mutation follows at the BL&LRO. A suit for specific performance or for partition is filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata or in the district court at Alipore or Barasat, depending on the value and the location.
Our property law practice advises on the consents before the deed is drafted, and the registration practice handles the conveyance. Where a co-owner has refused, the specific performance practice deals with the claim, and where the buyer wants a division, the partition practice is the route.
Can one co-owner sell the whole property?
He can sign a deed that purports to sell the whole, but it conveys only his share. The buyer becomes a co-owner with the others, and the deed is ineffective as to their shares. A buyer who pays for the whole on the strength of one signature has paid for a share, and his remedy is against the seller for the deficiency.
What if a co-owner dies before the sale is completed?
His share devolves on his heirs, and they must be brought on the record and must join the deed. The sale cannot proceed on the strength of the deceased co-owner's agreement, unless his heirs adopt it. The mutation in the heirs' names should be completed before the conveyance, so that the deed and the record agree.
Does the buyer have to file a partition suit?
Only if he has bought a share and wants the property divided. A buyer who has bought the whole, with all the co-owners joining, has no need of a partition. A buyer who has bought a share can hold it, negotiate a buy-out, or sue for partition, and the choice depends on whether the other co-owners will deal.
Sale coowned property consent is a matter of signatures: co-ownership is a relationship the law does not force anyone to continue, and it does not allow anyone to force a sale either. The consent of every owner is the price of a clean conveyance, and the buyer who understands that asks for the signatures before he pays, not after.