14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

The mother's share in a Hindu family property

A mother's share depends on whose property is being divided. In her husband's own property she is a Class I heir under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and she takes a share equal to that of each son and each daughter. In the coparcenary property of the joint family she is not a coparcener, but she has a right of maintenance and residence, and when the coparceners divide the family property she is entitled to a share equal to a son's.

The distinction is the one that matters in practice, because a mutation application that treats the mother as having a life interest only, or omits her altogether, produces a record that is wrong on its face and can be corrected at any time by her or by her heirs.

Where the property was her husband's own

Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act sets out the heirs of a male Hindu dying intestate, and the widow is in Class I, along with the sons, the daughters and the mother of the deceased. Section 10 provides that the property devolves in equal shares among the heirs in the same entry, so the widow takes one share, and each son and each daughter takes one share.

A husband with a widow and two sons therefore leaves three shares, each of one-third, and the widow's share is her own absolute property, not a life estate. She can sell it, mortgage it, gift it, or leave it by will to whomever she chooses.

This is the position that families most often get wrong. The widow is recorded as a co-sharer with a "life interest" or as a "maintenance holder", and the sons proceed on the basis that the property will come to them on her death. It will not, unless she dies intestate without having dealt with it, in which case her own heirs take it under the same Act.

Where the property was joint family property

A mother is not a coparcener in a Mitakshara joint family. She does not acquire the property by birth, and she cannot demand partition in her own right as a coparcener can. Her rights are a right of maintenance and a right of residence in the family dwelling, and those rights are enforceable.

When the coparceners themselves divide the joint property, the traditional rule gives the widow a share equal to that of a son. That rule was given statutory form in the Hindu Women's Right to Property Act, 1937, and although that Act has been repealed, the principle continues to be applied in the working of the Hindu Succession Act, and it is the basis on which widows are joined as parties in partition suits and allotted a share.

The practical consequence is that a partition among the sons, without the mother being made a party and without a share being allotted to her, is a partition that does not bind her. She can sue for her share, and the suit will be entertained even years later, because her right is not extinguished by a partition to which she was not a party.

The 2005 amendment and the daughter

The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 changed the position of daughters, not of mothers. A daughter of a coparcener became a coparcener by birth, with the same rights and liabilities as a son, and the Supreme Court has held that the right is by birth and applies even where the father died before the amendment came into force.

For the mother, the amendment's significance is indirect. It increased the number of shares in the coparcenary, and it removed the provision that had restricted a daughter's right to reside in the family dwelling house. Where the family property is now divided, the widow's share and the daughters' shares are computed on the enlarged coparcenary.

Her own property is protected by section 14, which converts a woman's limited estate into an absolute one. Property held by a mother as a widow's estate, or as a maintenance grant, is her absolute property, and her heirs take it as such.

Maintenance, residence and the money claim

A mother can claim maintenance from her children, sons and daughters alike, under the summary provision in the criminal procedure law, now section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, where she is unable to maintain herself. The claim is against the children, and it is independent of any share in the property.

The right of residence in the family dwelling is a separate right, and it survives the partition. A widow who has been living in the family house cannot be turned out because the sons have divided the property and allotted the house to one of them; her right of residence continues, and the court will protect it.

How the mother's share is enforced

  1. A partition suit is filed joining all the coparceners and the widow, with a prayer that her share be allotted.
  2. In the alternative, a suit for declaration of her share in her husband's estate, where the property was his own and devolved on his death.
  3. An application for mutation recording her as a co-sharer in the khatian, where the record has omitted her.
  4. An application for maintenance under the summary provision, where the immediate need is support rather than a share.
  5. An application for an injunction where the sons are attempting to sell the property without her participation.

The choice depends on the property. If it was her husband's self-acquired property, her share arises on his death and is a matter of succession. If it was ancestral, her share arises on the partition, and she has to be joined in the suit.

What a sale without her consent looks like

A sale by the sons of the whole property, without the mother's signature, transfers only their shares. The purchaser becomes a co-owner with the mother, not the owner of the whole, and the mother can sue for partition and for possession of her share. Where the purchaser had notice of her right — and a record that shows her as an heir is notice — he cannot claim to be a bona fide purchaser without notice.

The same applies to a mortgage. A bank that takes security from the sons alone takes it subject to the mother's share, and the security is worth less than the loan file assumes.

The Kolkata forum

A partition suit, or a suit for declaration of the mother's share, is filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata or in the district court at Alipore or Barasat, according to the value and the location. The mutation application goes to the BL&LRO of the block. A maintenance application goes to the magistrate having jurisdiction where she resides.

Our partition practice handles the suit, and the maintenance practice deals with the support claim where that is the immediate need. For the record side of the same dispute, see property law.

Does the mother get an equal share with her sons?

In her husband's own property, yes, along with the daughters, and each takes one share. In the joint family property, she is not a coparcener, but on a partition among the coparceners she is entitled to a share equal to a son's. In both cases, the share is hers absolutely, and she can deal with it as she wishes.

Can the sons sell the property without her consent?

They can sell their own shares, and the purchaser becomes a co-owner. They cannot sell her share, and a deed that purports to do so is ineffective to that extent. The purchaser's remedy is against the sellers for the deficiency, and the mother's remedy is a suit for partition and possession of what is hers.

Can the mother leave her share to one child by will?

Yes. Her share is her absolute property, and she can dispose of it by will to any person, including one child to the exclusion of the others. If she dies without a will, her share devolves on her own heirs under the Hindu Succession Act, who will include the children and, in some cases, the husband's heirs, depending on the family.

The mother's position is therefore stronger than the family often assumes, and the record should say so. A khatian that records her as a co-sharer with an absolute share is a document that prevents the dispute; one that records a life interest creates it.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422